Histroy As Ethical Remembrance: Dhaka University, Shaheed Minar, and CP Gang’s ‘Bessha’ Banner – IX


Posted April 11, 2022 by pvcfilm

As bell hooks reminds us, "Language [itself] is also a place of struggle

 
They want to steal my words, silence my tongue," the first line of legendary singer and song-writer Abdul Latif’s immortal song, written in memory of the 1952 Language Movement.

The opening lines are followed on by, Koito jaha amar daday, koise taha amar babay, Words my granddad spoke, my daddy did repeat…

The birth of Bangladesh, nearly four and a half decades ago, has reinstated the language to the state (the central demand of the language movement). Maybe it is high time we moved away from eulogising Bangla endlessly (we are the only nation to have shed blood for our language, our sacrifice has gained international recognition, etc) to conducting a forensic examination of the language: its built-in sexism, the seepage of poisonous meanings into other words to render mute women speakers. Maybe we could place it beside other languages, languages spoken in equally patriarchal societies, to see how masculine supremacy is asserted in those, linguistically. For instance, democracy in Urdu is "jamhuriyat," an online search tells me, it has Roman (not Sanskrit) roots. The word for democracy in Arabic is "hukm ash-sha’b," government of the people (Orin Hargraves, 2011). Neither words seem to be connected to female chastity, or the male obsession to control and regulate it. Forensics and comparative analyses, I contend, are necessary to "de-besshafay" (as in decolonise) our minds.

Were there any protests against the CP Gang’s "bessha" banner? Of course not. Did anyone protest? I know of only two (I would of course love to be proven wrong).

CR Abrar wrote of his perplexity at the "stark stillness" of the rights activists and the women’s organisations, he condemned the "conscience keepers of the nation" for being silent, and wrote, "declaring an individual persona non grata to Shaheed Minar on grounds of being ‘intellectual prostitute’" is not only "offensive," but also "criminal" (The Daily Star, October 22, 2014).

Nurul Kabir, in a talk show soon after (‘Frontline,’ on Bangla Vision channel, October 20, 2014; interestingly, the anchor of the talk show is Motiur Rahman Chowdhury, editor, daily Manabzamin, his photo too, graces the CP Gang’s banner) was dismissive, he obliquely referred to the banner as being oshlil (vulgar), and implied that the CP Gang and other participants at the "laasher bhar" Shaheed Minar event, were orbachin (immature), and "jokers."

For the life of me I cannot understand why Abrar bhai and Kabir, two outspoken public intellectuals, Kabir, who I know to be very combative, failed to, at the very least, recognise the sexism inherent in the word "bessha."

Without going into the matter in great detail, I will end this section by quoting a passage from Geraldine Forbes’ book review (2001) of Sumanta Banerjee’s Under the Raj: Prostitution in Colonial Bengal, because I believe it partly assists in illuminating the problem,

In the epilogue Banerjee calls this a beginning and urges other historians to focus their attention on prostitution. Asking why this subject has not attracted more attention given the importance of prostitutes to the colonial authorities and bhadralok, Banerjee suggests historian sons of bhadralok fathers feared contamination with the topic. Here I think Banerjee is too dismissive of the gendered nature of scholarship and scholarly inquiry. To begin with, historians of the West as well as India scorned women and gender issues until well into the 1970s and even now gender and women are rarely integrated into the meta-narratives of Indian history.

Not engaging with feminism, not taking it seriously? Yes, that is very true of male academics and public intellectuals in Bangladesh (I’m sure it must be obvious to readers that I’m not speaking of token/rights-based mention of the "womens’ problem"). At the same time, it is important to add that women’s organisations do not engage with feminism either, that there is not any, so to speak, feminist debate among women’s organisations and activists, most of them largely rely on the policy documents of the European Union and the World Bank for intellectual guidance (theories of "women’s empowerment"), but that deserves a separate discussion.
https://www.mlflex.com/product/pvc-tarpaulin/
-- END ---
Share Facebook Twitter
Print Friendly and PDF DisclaimerReport Abuse
Contact Email [email protected]
Issued By pvcfilm
Country China
Categories Accounting , Advertising , Event
Tags pvc coated tarp , pvc film supplier , rigid clear film
Last Updated April 11, 2022